English RM News —
Memphis City Council Approves Firefighter Pay Raise Amidst Financial Scrutiny and Contract Dispute
Memphis City Hall became a stage for heated debate Tuesday night, December 16th, as the Memphis City Council and the Memphis Fire Fighters Association (MFFA) engaged in a contentious discussion surrounding finances, prior commitments, and the fiscal trajectory of the city. The focal point of the evening was the approval of a pay raise for the city’s firefighters.
Following a lengthy deliberation, the council voted 8-3-2 to grant Memphis firefighters a 2% pay increase. Councilmembers Rhonda Logan and Janika White opted to abstain from the vote, marking their neutrality on the matter. This decision marks a significant development after months of strained relations between the City of Memphis, the fire department, and its union representatives, a tension exacerbated by an ongoing lawsuit concerning a previously ratified pay agreement.
Concerns Over Financial Management and Justification for Raise
During the December 16th meeting, Councilman Chase Carlisle voiced strong reservations regarding the necessity and financial justification for the proposed raise. He challenged the narrative that the funds were readily available within existing city accounts.
“If we are going to make this decision, make it because you want to give Fire a raise,” Carlisle stated, directly addressing the council. “Stop telling me you have the money somewhere in the account.”
Carlisle further expressed apprehension about the city’s current financial health, warning that the readily accessible cash reserves might not accurately reflect the city’s long-term financial stability.
“We may have the cash in the account today, but that is not going to last if we don’t make changes soon,” he cautioned, highlighting the need for fiscal prudence and strategic adjustments.
Union Leaders Assert Contractual Obligations and Prior Agreements
In response to the council’s concerns, union leaders forcefully argued that the City of Memphis possesses the necessary financial resources and, more importantly, that the pay increase was a pre-existing condition stipulated in a multi-year contract.
Thomas Malone, president of the Memphis Fire Fighters Association, emphasized the contractual nature of the agreement. “I think everybody got amnesia at the fact that we did a three-year contract,” Malone stated. “We were not in negotiations this year. Let me repeat that — we were not in negotiations this year.”
Malone clarified that the contract, officially signed in 2024 by Mayor Paul Young and other senior city officials, included a provision for a 5% pay increase for firefighters, which was slated to take effect on July 1, 2025. However, the City of Memphis had only implemented a partial increase, falling short of the agreed-upon terms.
According to the MFFA, the council’s recent vote is a step towards rectifying this shortfall and bringing firefighter compensation closer to the originally promised figures. Despite this progress, the legal dispute remains active.
“It has no impact on the budget, as they all tried to allude to — acting like we’re trying to break the city,” Malone asserted, refuting claims that the union’s demands were financially detrimental. “The money is in the fire department’s budget, let alone in the general fund budget of the city.”
Malone characterized the council’s approval as a long-overdue fulfillment of a commitment made to the firefighters.
A Step Towards Honoring Promises and Back Pay
“This is the right thing to do for the men and women of the Memphis Fire Department,” Malone declared. “They’ve been expecting this. They’ve been waiting on it. It was promised to them 18 months ago, longer now, and we’re glad to bring this to an end.”
Beyond the immediate pay adjustment, the City of Memphis is also obligated to provide firefighters with back pay for the period extending from the original agreement’s intended effective date.
“All this is is a restoration; giving back to the firefighters what they took away from them,” Malone explained, underscoring the compensatory nature of the payment.
Ongoing Legal Battle and Future Implications
The MFFA initiated a lawsuit against the City of Memphis in July 2025, following the union’s realization that the council did not intend to honor the contract signed the previous year. This lawsuit continues to be a significant point of contention.
The dispute has led to several acrimonious exchanges during recent council meetings. In the meeting preceding Tuesday’s vote, the union issued a statement criticizing Councilwoman Yolanda Cooper-Sutton for remarks made during discussions about the pay raise.
While the council’s approval on December 16th represents a positive development for the firefighters, the legal battle between the union and the city is far from over. The ultimate resolution of this lawsuit could have lasting implications for future firefighter compensation and labor relations within Memphis.